What to Look for in a Marketing Company for Your Firm
Sean McNamaraHiring a marketing company is one of the bigger decisions a firm makes, and most proposals look alike on paper. Here are the three questions that separate a real partner from a polished pitch, and what a good answer sounds like.
Most firms hire a marketing company the same way they would hire any vendor. They collect a few proposals, compare the prices, and go with the one that felt most confident in the meeting. That approach is understandable, and it tends to produce a decision that looks fine for about six months. The trouble is that marketing proposals are written to look alike. Nearly all of them promise more visibility, more leads, and a dedicated team. The differences that actually matter sit underneath that language, and you have to ask for them directly.
After more than a decade of building websites and marketing for law firms, I have found that three questions do most of the work. A good partner will answer all three clearly and without hesitation. If the answers come back vague, that tells you something too.
1. Who will actually do the work?
This is the question that proposals are least likely to answer on their own. The people in the pitch meeting are often senior, experienced, and genuinely impressive. The people who write your content, build your pages, and manage your campaigns may be someone else entirely, and you may never meet them.
That arrangement is common, and it is not automatically a problem. What matters is that you know it going in. Ask for the names and roles of the people who will handle your account week to week. Ask how long they have done this kind of work and whether they have worked with firms in your practice area. Ask what happens when your contact leaves, because in this industry, people do.
A strong answer sounds specific. “Here is who writes your content, here is who handles search, and here is who you call when something needs attention.” You should come away knowing exactly who is responsible for your firm’s presence.
2. How will you show me what is working?
Every marketing company reports. The question is what they report and whether it connects to anything you care about. Traffic, impressions, and rankings are easy to show and easy to grow. They are also a long way from the thing your firm actually measures, which is signed clients.
This is where the concept of attribution comes in. Attribution simply means tracing a new client back to where they first found you: a search, an ad, a referral, a directory listing. A company that takes attribution seriously can show you, in plain terms, which efforts are producing consultations and which are producing noise. A company that does not will tend to show you activity instead of outcomes.
Ask to see a sample report before you sign. Look at whether it follows the path from first click to phone call to signed matter, or whether it stops at the website. Pay attention to how results are expressed, too. A report full of large dollar figures feels impressive, but those numbers are easy to inflate and hard to verify. Rates, such as how many calls became consultations and how many consultations became clients, are far harder to dress up. We wrote about this in more depth in why we report in rates, not dollars.
It is also worth asking about the cadence. Monthly reporting keeps everyone honest about what is moving. A quarterly strategy conversation gives you room to adjust direction. The right rhythm depends on how much you are investing, but there should be one, and it should be written into the agreement.
3. Do you understand my profession’s advertising rules?
This is the question that separates firms-first marketing companies from generalists. Attorney advertising is governed by rules that most marketers never encounter. In North Carolina, Rule 7.1 of the Rules of Professional Conduct prohibits communications about a lawyer’s services that are false or misleading, and the State Bar’s guidance treats things like unqualified claims of past results and promises of outcomes with real caution. Other states add their own requirements, and some are considerably stricter.
A marketing company does not need to be your ethics counsel. That remains your responsibility, and a good partner will say so. What they should do is know the rules well enough to avoid creating problems for you. Ask how they handle case results, testimonials, and words like “best” or “specialist.” Ask whether they have a review process before anything publishes under your firm’s name. The answer should make it clear they have thought about this before you raised it.
A company that treats your bar rules as an afterthought is asking you to carry risk you did not agree to take on.
A few things worth checking before you sign
Beyond those three questions, a handful of practical details are worth confirming in writing:
- Ownership. Your domain, website, content, and accounts should be in your firm’s name. If the relationship ends, everything you paid for should stay with you. We covered this in own your website, don’t rent it.
- Contract terms. Understand the length of the commitment and what it takes to leave. Long lock-ins are a signal worth weighing.
- Their own presence. Look at the company’s own website and content. A firm that builds strong sites and writes useful material for clients usually does the same for itself.
- Fit with your practice. Experience with firms like yours shortens the learning curve considerably. Ask for examples of work they have built.
The decision underneath the decision
Choosing a marketing company is ultimately a decision about trust. You are handing someone the way your firm introduces itself to people who need help, often at a difficult moment in their lives. The right partner treats that with the seriousness it deserves. They learn your firm before they build anything, they tell you plainly what is working, and they protect you from mistakes you should never have to worry about.
If you are reviewing proposals this season, bring these three questions to every meeting. The answers will tell you more than any pitch deck. And if you would like to hear how we would answer them for your firm, we are always glad to have that conversation.
Monthly website tips
Get one practical website tip each month
Sean and Joy write it, it takes two minutes to read, and you can unsubscribe anytime.